Ophelea, "Out There"
« Where are all the editors?What Do You Want? »

Shirking Our Responsibilties

2007-05-15

Permalink 14:59:37, by Ophelea
Categories: Behavior, Online

Shirking Our Responsibilties

Those who know me find me infuriating at times. I love to argue. Not in the common sense of the word. But the true definition: to consider the pros and cons of: DISCUSS (argue an issue). This is my high – it’s how I learn best. Many would call me stubborn but in actuality I’m quite pliable, you just have to argue your point well so that I can learn from you. Then give me time to mull it over.

This means I have no fear of confrontation.

Fear of confrontation baffles me. So many “bad” things happen because people simply don’t say, “no, you can’t do that”. The odd thing is, if it were a child behaving badly – even one not your own – a person usually doesn’t hesitate with a “no!” But an adult behaving badly? We look the other way.

Me, not so much.

Follow up:

This is the other thing about me that infuriates (or embarrasses) those who know me. I will subtly (or not so subtly) let an adult know they’re behaving badly.

I do it in games, too. Frequently. I think it’s why I play Xbox Live without a headset. I’d spend too much time annoyed with childish behaviors. The children don’t bother me when they act childish – they’re children! But…hey, having fun doesn’t mean acting childish! I firmly believe in play.

Ellen DeGeneres once said that she thought that part of what’s wrong with the world today is that when we grow up, we forget how to play. So, the next time you’re on the street? Run up to someone and say, “Tag! You’re it!” Try it sometime. One out of five will play with you!

There’s something that’s key in what Ellen says: play Tag. We all know the rules of Tag. And when someone acts badly? It’s not fun anymore so we either don’t play with that person or stop playing altogether. That’s rather how most social norms work. We have expected rules of behavior and when people break outside of those rules we only accept it to a point.

Along comes the internet…anonymity, an audience, and competition. Can you imagine a more volatile situation given the fact that there were no social norms for behavior when we all got together to play? And since that time, we’ve all just shirked our responsibilities because well…we’d not only have to confront one another but take a hard look at ourselves.

What’s worse? That we may have contributed to the cheating and griefing and plethora of bad behaviors in gaming? Or that we did nothing and have let them permeate our game space and now consider them normal?

5 comments

Comment from: Noelle [Visitor] Email
In an MMO situation, I'm not sure how much you can do to change the behavior of other players. You can refuse to interact with them. You can try to point out their bad behavior (which usually results in them screaming profanity and then you go back to the ignore plan). If their behavior violates the games stated terms of service you can report them. I've done all 3, though /ignore is my preferred method. I do know that while I let my daughter play Horizons, I would never let her play WoW. Much different community personality.
2007-05-15 @ 19:18
Comment from: Chris [Visitor] Email · http://onlyagame.typepad.com
Only 1 in 5? Wow, what dull adults we've been creating. ;)

This speaks directly to an ethical issue... The problem in the online space is the lack of accountability, which enables people to behave "lawlessly". Many of those doing so are children. We are not their parents, and so we hold no authority with them. (Although in the US, I wonder how many parents actually maintain authority over their children...)

As an idle thought, what if the instances (does the term shard now apply universally in this context?) of each virtual world were arranged like a medieval conception of afterlife. Players reward other players by tagging them as 'friendly'. The more friendly-tagged players become, the more they "climb the ladder" to friendlier servers. (Of course, we might think it better to go the other way, and descend unfriendly players to more hellish domains - but any such system would be a tool for griefers to abuse).

Perhaps it would be sufficient to sort the players into instances by their age. ;)

It's an interesting area, but not one in which solutions will come easily. Experimentation in virtual world structure will eventually provide some progress, I suspect, but as to when - who can say!

Best wishes!
2007-05-16 @ 08:11
Comment from: Chris [Visitor] · http://onlyagame.typepad.com
Ugh, I appreciate you need to get revenue, but adverts embedded in our comment text? I feel dirty... :|
2007-05-16 @ 08:14
Comment from: Ophelea [Member]
The adverts just spider the page - it doesn't seem them as a separate part - look for a common theme and try to place a maximum number (6 or 8? I think) accordingly. So...it's the theme it's looking for. If your comments don't fit the theme, it wouldn't pull anything.

Or, I could just write longer posts! (I'll see if we can force them in the original text but in short posts it bunches them all up together)
2007-05-16 @ 12:30
Comment from: SeanW [Visitor] Email · http://www.seanw.com
It's funny you mention to play tag - I just watched a video on Xbox Live that I thought was genius. It's the cops and robbers video - if you can, go download it from the videos section, it's cheap (free). :)
2007-06-19 @ 06:38

Leave a comment


Your email address will not be revealed on this site.

Your URL will be displayed.
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Name, email & website)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will not be revealed.)
December 2014
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
 << <   > >>
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30 31        

  • Thinking is more interesting than knowing, but less interesting than looking. - Goethe
  • He who can take no great interest in what is small will take false interest in what is great. - Ruskin
  • We don't know who discovered water, but we know it wasn't the fish. - McLuhan

Search

XML Feeds

powered by b2evolution free blog software